XMR $448.54
FIRO $0.70
ZANO $8.17
FUSD $1.00
DAIX $1.00

Please login

Region:

Current view: Threads | Classic
Sort by: Tips | New

NitroEggs math ain't mathing...

SoulReaver Donor - Resistor Mediator Top Seller
5 (3)
Posts: 85
Earned: 0.003 XMR
Tipped: 0 XMR
Jun 9 07:04
(0)
(0)
#1374
Some of you may've heard the platform called NitroEggs.
https://nitroeggs.com/
https://x.com/NitroEggs

Premise is that you purchase a chicken from this person, and they pay you dividends from earnings.
But the math of this ain't mathing...

It's a long story I'm leaving analysis of below, but in short there's good chance you'll earn nothing and you'll lose your investment, so, don't get into it...

You might prefer reading it w/ better formatting:
https://claude.ai/public/artifacts/b7bdbb01-4bd4-4484-93b6-b3ea9d34cc01

# NitroEggs Explained Simply: What Backing a Hen Actually Pays

This is a plain-language version of a full financial breakdown. It uses only NitroEggs' own published numbers, and it assumes they pay everything on time and the farm performs exactly as they claim. Even on those generous terms, the result is a loss for you. Here is the whole picture, step by step.

## The bottom line first

If you back a hen for $15 and everything goes perfectly, you end up with less money than you put in. In the best realistic case you get back about **76 cents for every dollar**, a loss of roughly **25%**. There is no point during the 15 months where cashing out leaves you ahead. The only way to even break even is to never cash out and keep collecting payments for about 20 months straight with no missed payment, and the website itself says payments are sent by hand and are not guaranteed.

## How it works

You pay $15 to "back a hen." In return they promise to send you a share of the money from selling that hen's eggs, a little every 10 days or so. You can also try to sell your stake back later if you change your mind. There is no token and no contract; everything is tracked by hand in their own private records, and you are paid in Monero.

## What one hen earns (their own numbers)

- A hen lays about 18 eggs a month.
- They sell eggs at about 15 cents each, so one hen brings in about $2.70 a month.
- They subtract feed (about $1.19 a month), leaving about $1.51.
- You get half of that, so about **76 cents per hen per month**, or about **$9.06 a year**.

On a $15 stake, $9.06 a year looks like about a 60% return, and that is the number they lead with. But it only counts the money coming in. It ignores what happens to your original $15, which is the whole problem.

## The part they bury: your $15 slowly expires

Your $15 does not come back. In the fine print, the value of your stake drops a little every month and reaches zero after 15 months. So while you collect those small egg payments, the value of your original stake is melting away at the same time, and the payments never add back up to the $15 you started with.

Think of it like a prepaid card that loses value every month until it is worth nothing after 15 months, while handing you back small change that never totals what you loaded onto it.

## The full picture: what you get back if you cash out at different times

This is the chart. It assumes every payment arrives on time and they honor your request to sell your stake back. The "sell-back value" already includes the 10% fee they charge to cash out.

| If you cash out at... | Egg payments collected so far | Sell-back value of your stake (after 10% fee) | Total you have gotten back | Where you stand |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Right away | $0.00 | $13.50 | $13.50 | down 10.0% |
| 3 months | $2.27 | $10.80 | $13.07 | down 12.9% |
| 6 months | $4.53 | $8.10 | $12.63 | down 15.8% |
| 9 months | $6.80 | $5.40 | $12.20 | down 18.7% |
| 12 months | $9.06 | $2.70 | $11.76 | down 21.6% |
| 15 months | $11.33 | $0.00 | $11.33 | down 24.5% |
| ~20 months (never cash out, just keep collecting) | $15.10 | $0.00 | $15.10 | up 0.7% |

Read across any row: every time you cash out, you lose money, because your stake has shrunk and they take a 10% fee on top. The longer you wait and then cash out, the worse it gets, bottoming at a 25% loss right when your stake hits zero at 15 months.

## Why you basically cannot win

To get your original $15 back from the egg payments alone, you would need about 20 months of payments at 76 cents a month. But your stake is treated as "used up" after 15 months. So the hen runs out of value before it has paid back what you put in. The only way to come out slightly ahead is to never cash out and keep getting paid past 20 months, with no payment ever missed.

Put another way, as an effective interest rate the standard case (holding to 15 months) works out to about **minus 33% a year**. Your money shrinks; it does not grow.

## If something goes wrong, it is your loss

The website says disease, bad weather, dead chickens, falling egg prices, and equipment problems are all your risk, not theirs. Your payments come from a shared pool across all the backed hens, so if the flock does badly, your payments shrink, while your stake keeps expiring on schedule no matter what. They keep the chickens and their half of the egg money regardless.

## The chickens cost them far less than $15

A real chicken is cheap. A baby chick costs a dollar or two. A grown laying hen costs maybe five to nine dollars. You are paying $15 for a "share" of a bird that costs them a small fraction of that. So on every hen they:

- take your $15;
- spend a few dollars on the actual bird and keep it;
- pocket the difference immediately;
- keep half the egg money for as long as the hen lays;
- never owe you your $15 back;
- and carry none of the risk.

## It gets worse once you count the real costs

Their math only subtracts feed. A real farm also pays for labor, replacing old hens, buildings and equipment wearing out, electricity, packaging, transport, dead birds, vet bills, broken eggs, and running the website and camera. Once you include normal costs like those, your payments would be closer to about **44 cents a month** instead of 76, you would get back **less than half** of your $15 over the hen's life, and it would take **more than 34 months** of payments just to break even. So the numbers in the chart above are the best case, not the likely case.

## What is fair to say for them

To their credit, the website is honest that this is risky and not guaranteed. That is better than many schemes. But honesty about the risk does not change the math. Even taking every word at face value, you lose money.

## A note on the math

NitroEggs only publishes the starting value ($15) and the ending value ($0 after 15 months) of your stake, plus the 10% fee. We assumed the value drops in a straight line in between, which is the most natural reading. The three most important conclusions do not depend on that assumption: you lose 10% if you cash out immediately (just the fee), you are down about 25% if you hold to 15 months (your stake is zero by then), and it takes about 20 months of payments to break even. Those hold no matter how the value drops in between.

## What this does not cover

This breakdown is only about the money math. It assumes the farm is real, performs as claimed, and that they actually pay you. It does not account for other risks: that Monero payments cannot be reversed if anything goes wrong, that the records are kept privately by them with no independent way to check, that the operators are anonymous, and that you have no real way to make them pay. Those would only make things worse.

---

*Based on NitroEggs' own published figures (their payouts calculator and sell-back terms), as of June 2026.*k terms), as of June 2026.
Edited: Jun 30 09:23
Tip Monero to SoulReaver
QR Code 8AJJt5FoxgKapYk69YgSLXPaSBYd88hghg32ie25ZXGSFFYgVeKT4ytLkPoCsnJGE3gQninbK6JDUAX4qNCRUqfXFwXe3Hm
Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Publish Tip to SoulReaver

Please login to publish your tip

std_vector
5 (5)
Posts: 7
Earned: 0.011 XMR
Tipped: 0 XMR
Jun 9 12:03
(0)
(1)
#1375
Tbh I expected not AI generated analysis.
Tip Monero to std_vector
QR Code 44DG6jgByodcEaqKimcvm3QYKfxVWFyzvLLQjLVYKbe2f4kx3oLKJuvGTfduW1AXk13hdBdwaBQk18n5F4oEkarr1ULrjtG
Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to std_vector

std_vector has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to std_vector

std_vector has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to std_vector

std_vector has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to std_vector

std_vector has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Publish Tip to std_vector

Please login to publish your tip

std_vector
5 (5)
Posts: 7
Earned: 0.011 XMR
Tipped: 0 XMR
Jun 9 12:18
(0)
(0)
#1376
And speaking about NitroEggs itself. Maybe they should raise price for egg. I don't know exactly about prices in Serbia, but I've just opened random video on youtube from supermarket, and saw pack of 10 eggs costs 2.23$, so ~0.25$ per egg. But it's egg from large "industrial" farm, NittroEggs looks more like "eco farm" which usually have higher prices due to lower volume. With 0.25$ per egg person will get 9.93$ per month instead of current 2.27. Huge difference.
Tip Monero to std_vector
QR Code 44DG6jgByodcEaqKimcvm3QYKfxVWFyzvLLQjLVYKbe2f4kx3oLKJuvGTfduW1AXk13hdBdwaBQk18n5F4oEkarr1ULrjtG
Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to std_vector

std_vector has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to std_vector

std_vector has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to std_vector

std_vector has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to std_vector

std_vector has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Publish Tip to std_vector

Please login to publish your tip

Camylopez Mediator Bond Donor - Liberator Top Seller
5 (28)
Posts: 37
Earned: 0 XMR
Tipped: 0 XMR
Jun 9 13:16
(1)
(0)
#1377
lol, do you not remember recyclix in Poland?

some people never learn.
Tip Monero to Camylopez
QR Code 87V1oyh1q7Zh2ma2i15DG5Ywwj6wjSYYPEHuPnX3hkTMKqaCe9LvVQpZc5C4Fe6QeCXfyWHruQAP4Y6v5WSXAutE2S7vLVV
Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to Camylopez

Camylopez has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to Camylopez

Camylopez has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to Camylopez

Camylopez has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to Camylopez

Camylopez has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Publish Tip to Camylopez

Please login to publish your tip

Camylopez Mediator Bond Donor - Liberator Top Seller
5 (28)
Posts: 37
Earned: 0 XMR
Tipped: 0 XMR
Jun 9 13:17
(1)
(0)
#1378
there was a large spate of Ponzi like scams modelled on the stockvel rampaging through African countries back in 2014, this also smacks of these.
Tip Monero to Camylopez
QR Code 87V1oyh1q7Zh2ma2i15DG5Ywwj6wjSYYPEHuPnX3hkTMKqaCe9LvVQpZc5C4Fe6QeCXfyWHruQAP4Y6v5WSXAutE2S7vLVV
Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to Camylopez

Camylopez has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to Camylopez

Camylopez has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to Camylopez

Camylopez has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to Camylopez

Camylopez has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Publish Tip to Camylopez

Please login to publish your tip

NitroEggs
N/A (0)
Posts: 1
Earned: 0 XMR
Tipped: 0 XMR
Jun 11 19:24
(1)
(1)
#1385
Hi, NitroEggs founder here. Thanks for the analysis, genuinely. It used our published numbers and it exposed a real problem, not with the math but with how unclear our site was.
The analysis assumes a hen share stops existing after 15 months. It does not. Shares receive payouts for the entire laying life of the hen. The 15 month schedule only applies to the optional early exit buyback for people who want out before the hen has paid for itself. If you simply hold, you collect your share of egg revenue for as long as the hen produces. Break even on payouts alone is around 20 months at current estimates and everything after that is profit. That was not stated clearly on the site and that is on me. I already explained this on our Twitter and the site text will follow.
On the Ponzi comparison. Payouts are funded exclusively from egg sales, not from new backers money. That is exactly why the numbers look small and unsexy. Around 0.75 dollars per hen per month is what eggs actually earn after feed. A Ponzi promises more than the underlying asset can produce. We publish exactly what it produces, feed costs included, and the farm runs on a public 24/7 camera.
On egg pricing, fair point. The 0.15 price is set low on purpose. At this stage the priority is that every single egg gets sold, even to wholesale buyers, so payouts go out every cycle without interruption. As we break into direct retail, realized prices should go up, and since backers receive 50% of net revenue, payouts rise together with them.
Happy to answer anything else here.
Tip Monero to NitroEggs

NitroEggs has not setup a {COIN} tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to NitroEggs

NitroEggs has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to NitroEggs

NitroEggs has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to NitroEggs

NitroEggs has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to NitroEggs

NitroEggs has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Publish Tip to NitroEggs

NitroEggs has not setup a {COIN} tip address yet.

SoulReaver Donor - Resistor Mediator Top Seller
5 (3)
Posts: 85
Earned: 0.003 XMR
Tipped: 0 XMR
Jun 30 09:35
(0)
(0)
#1553
Reply to post #1385
NitroEggs "Break even on payouts alone is around 20 months... and everything after that is profit."

You are conveniently leaving out the reality of a hen's productivity decline over time. A chicken isn't a fixed yield machine.

While hens can lay okay up to 24 months, their egg production naturally drops as they age. We obviously don't know the exact math or how steep the drop-off is for your specific flock, but that $1.19/month feed cost stays the same.

To actually hit a 20 month break even, a hen would need to maintain peak production the entire time. As her output inevitably slows in her second year, the flat feed cost may increasingly eat into whatever margin is left. Without knowing the exact numbers, it is safe to say those payouts will shrink as the hen ages, making that "pure profit" phase a lot harder to actually reach than you suggest.
Tip Monero to SoulReaver
QR Code 8AJJt5FoxgKapYk69YgSLXPaSBYd88hghg32ie25ZXGSFFYgVeKT4ytLkPoCsnJGE3gQninbK6JDUAX4qNCRUqfXFwXe3Hm
Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Publish Tip to SoulReaver

Please login to publish your tip

MoneroMAGO Donor - Resistor Top Seller
5 (370)
Posts: 7
Earned: 0 XMR
Tipped: 0 XMR
Jun 20 21:10
(1)
(0)
#1468
Better to use a bank haha
Tip Monero to MoneroMAGO
QR Code 83dwnhgP4nG7T5qRXjWNEX8W6aUMTJAWvFz7co5PKPJY44Ff7G5shxS4uePd6DDh1QEpBef1tBtGEdBvABUgFGofFjCib4H
Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to MoneroMAGO

MoneroMAGO has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to MoneroMAGO

MoneroMAGO has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to MoneroMAGO

MoneroMAGO has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to MoneroMAGO

MoneroMAGO has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Publish Tip to MoneroMAGO

Please login to publish your tip

xaibott Mediator Top Seller
5 (9)
Posts: 4
Earned: 0 XMR
Tipped: 0 XMR
Jul 17 00:26
(0)
(0)
#1682
Buy a chicken and get dividends reminds me of this ad of a gold buying site where they hold your gold and it earns you interest in more gold-

But at least a chicken can lay more eggs! Gold doesn't grow via division xD

I'd be more than willing to contribute to some sort of community crop share / farming initiative, hopefully one manifests itself in my area.
Tip Monero to xaibott

xaibott has not setup a {COIN} tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to xaibott

xaibott has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to xaibott

xaibott has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to xaibott

xaibott has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to xaibott

xaibott has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Publish Tip to xaibott

xaibott has not setup a {COIN} tip address yet.

SoulReaver Donor - Resistor Mediator Top Seller
5 (3)
Posts: 85
Earned: 0.003 XMR
Tipped: 0 XMR
Jul 17 18:38
(0)
(0)
#1685
Reply to post #1682
You read the analysis, this one doesn't sound like the best investment to make based on numbers and risk profile.
Anon is good and all, but not great for anonymous investment schemes.
Here's a similar story of a guy collecting money for farm dividents and disappearing:
https://www.dailysabah.com/business/economy/turkish-farm-bank-ponzi-founder-gets-over-45370-years-in-prison

I'm not saying nitroeggss will do this, I'm saying risk is high.
Tip Monero to SoulReaver
QR Code 8AJJt5FoxgKapYk69YgSLXPaSBYd88hghg32ie25ZXGSFFYgVeKT4ytLkPoCsnJGE3gQninbK6JDUAX4qNCRUqfXFwXe3Hm
Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Publish Tip to SoulReaver

Please login to publish your tip

SoulReaver Donor - Resistor Mediator Top Seller
5 (3)
Posts: 85
Earned: 0.003 XMR
Tipped: 0 XMR
Jul 31 12:21
(0)
(0)
#1822
When you have nothing left but faith, you have everything you need to begin again.
Starting from seventeen
What happened
↓
Statement to holders
The flock was lost to heat. Seventeen hens survived.
During an extreme heat wave, the flock died of heat stress. Out of more than 3,000 birds, seventeen are alive.

The official heat warning for the country was issued several days later. At the time it happened, no warning was in place. I mention it because it is a fact, not because it changes anything — the birds were in my care and the loss is mine to answer for.

Live hens
17
Payouts
Paused
Sell-back
Closed
New shares
Not for sale
The coop after the loss. The image is blurred.
Blurred deliberately. You do not need to look at it.
When you registered, you accepted the Terms of Use and the risks published on this page. Section 12 of the Terms states plainly that hens may stop laying, become sick, die, or require replacement. Section 15 excludes liability for farm losses. Section 09 states that a sell-back is a request, subject to available funds — not a guaranteed buy-back.

I am quoting my own terms not to hide behind them, but because you deserve to see exactly what was and was not promised, before I tell you what I intend to do anyway. They are unchanged and remain where they have always been: the risk section below, the Terms of Use, and the whitepaper.

The only thing I can do right now, with my own means, is this: an incubator, fertilised eggs from my own birds, and hens raised by me. I have already begun buying the incubator. It is not a plan I can guarantee, and I will not put a number or a date on it, because I would only be inventing one. It is the only road open to me at this moment, and I am taking it.

Hens will come back in waves, not all at once. Each wave is divided proportionally among all holders, by the number of shares held. Whoever holds more receives more, but no one waits behind anyone else. That rule is fixed and I will not change it later.

What I will not do is promise you an outcome I cannot guarantee. I do not know today whether I can restore the flock to the number it was, or how long that would take. What I can promise is that I will not walk away from it quietly, and that you will hear the truth from me either way.

13 August
Next update. I need time before I can say more, and I will not be answering messages until then.

Smells like rug pull to me?
Edited: Jul 31 12:21
Tip Monero to SoulReaver
QR Code 8AJJt5FoxgKapYk69YgSLXPaSBYd88hghg32ie25ZXGSFFYgVeKT4ytLkPoCsnJGE3gQninbK6JDUAX4qNCRUqfXFwXe3Hm
Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Tip Wrapped DAI (ZANO) to SoulReaver

SoulReaver has not setup a Wrapped DAI (ZANO) tip address yet.

Publish Tip to SoulReaver

Please login to publish your tip

Page:
1
You must login in order to publish a post